Redline Drafting: Skill Test Contest for $100K+ of Freelance Work

in Oil & Gas held by pg
Contest Ended, Winner(s) have been selected.
  • Open
  • Choosing Finalist
  • Ended
Share
Description:
We're looking for 5+ freelance drafters to help with redline drafting work over the next 12 months (est. start in late-January). The work will be for several of Canada's largest O&G companies.

This purpose of this contest is to find contractors with the skills needed to help with our future redline work. Our draftsman will review the entries and award the prize to the top 5 freelance experts. After this first contest, we'll delegate work directly to the best freelancers through private projects. Past experience with the oil and gas industry is a big plus.
Wants:
We've uploaded the two PDF's with the redline mark-ups, which are going to be used for our evaluation. We've also uploaded the dwg files (pre-edits), which are the AutoCAD files to edit. We'll accept submissions with any of the following software: AutoCAD, CADworx or PROCAD software
Software:
  1. AutoCAD
  2. CADWorx Plant
  3. PROCAD
Post Similar Contest
Prepaid Prize Prepaid Prize
  • Prize #1: Under $799
  • Prize #2: Under $799
  • Prize #3: Under $799
  • Prize #4: Under $799
  • Prize #5: Under $799
Project Info
  • Created: 17 Dec, 2012
  • Ended: 13 Jan, 2013
  • Entries: 53
  • Designers: 46
Report Contest
Attachments

Entries

= Buyer's Rating
1st Winner
#1 Redline.Drafting.01 by Zaher
Download Files
18 Dec, 2012
3rd Winner
#11 Redline Drafting by vins
Download Files
18 Dec, 2012
#27 1355769435083 and 1355769472082 by plantonline
Download Files
22 Dec, 2012
#53 Re-work by Dual2
Download Files
8 Jan, 2013
#52 1355769472082-0102-020-533-01_Rev_32.dwg & 1355769435083-OLDS-020016301_Rev-3 by nilima_16
Declined
Download Files
7 Jan, 2013
#34 082-0102-020-533-01 by Ravi Sharma
Declined
Download Files
25 Dec, 2012
#36 Redline Drafting: Skill Test Contest by Slash
Declined
Download Files
26 Dec, 2012
#38 Skill test -ED by Endzi
Declined
Download Files
26 Dec, 2012
#42 1. 1355769472082-0102-020-533-01, 2. 1355769435083-OLDS-020016301 by Arpit Gupta
Declined
Download Files
28 Dec, 2012
#44 1355769435083-OLDS-020016301 & 1355769472082-0102-020-533-01 by Amogh
Declined
Download Files
31 Dec, 2012
#46 Olds Gas Plant & Quirk Creek Gas Plant P&ID by Za2Sa
Declined
Download Files
3 Jan, 2013
#48 P&ID Pilot Jobs for Redline Markups by Krsna
Declined
Download Files
6 Jan, 2013
#10 082-0102-020-533 01 Rev 32 by Christine
Declined
Download Files
18 Dec, 2012
#15 R32, R3 by NehaParikh
Declined
Download Files
19 Dec, 2012
#8 FIN1355769472082-0102-020-533-01 by Corty
Declined
Download Files
18 Dec, 2012
#19 Redline Drafting: Skill Test Contest for $100K+ of Freelance Work by Kwikcad
Declined
Download Files
20 Dec, 2012
#23 1355769472082-0102-020-533-01.DWG / 1355769435083-OLDS-020016301.dwg by arunkarthikdr
Declined
Download Files
21 Dec, 2012
4th Winner
#13 Redline Drafting Skill Test by Dual2
Download Files
18 Dec, 2012
5th Winner
#14 Oil and Gas Projects - Redline Skills Test by pschonfeldt
Download Files
19 Dec, 2012
#47 OIL AND PIPING LAYOUT DRAWING UPDATE AS PER EDIT by GURU
Download Files
6 Jan, 2013
#43 red line by erick 77
Declined
Download Files
28 Dec, 2012
#35 083-OLDS-020016301.dwg by Ravi Sharma
Declined
Download Files
25 Dec, 2012
#39 Skill test 2 - ED by Endzi
Declined
Download Files
26 Dec, 2012
#33 Supply Upgrade Of LPG Stogare & Renovation of Water Treatment (P&ID) by Hyder Ali
Declined
Download Files
23 Dec, 2012
#51 OLDS GAS PLANT by mina
Declined
Download Files
7 Jan, 2013
#9 FIN1355769435083-OLDS-020016301 by Corty
Declined
Download Files
18 Dec, 2012
#18 Redline Drafting: Skill Test Contest for $100K+ of Freelance Work by CADmate
Declined
Download Files
20 Dec, 2012
#20 1355769472082-0102-020-533-01_macjulius by macjulius
Declined
Download Files
20 Dec, 2012
#5 OLDS GAS PLANT L.P.G. STORAGE by Tanseer
Declined
Download Files
18 Dec, 2012
#24 Red line drafting contest by James Johnson
Declined
Download Files
21 Dec, 2012

Discussion

rohit1989

2 Feb, 2014

Kwikcad

Designer

21 Jan, 2013
Hi PG,

Just a few question on this. I though that the purpose of this contest is not just to test the ability of the drafter on how to follow the redlines but also knowledge and familiarity of piping design and drafting. I agree with cadmate that there is no such tee fitting that header is smaller than the branch. Try to look on the T808A, there&;s a line with 4" valve connected directly to 3" line after the 4X3 concentric fitting. I think that 4" line I am referring should be connected before the 4X3 reducer. Also try look on the whole P&ID, 4" valve uses flange connection. I don&;t see any top drafter who uses that connection on the additional valves shown on the redlines. Hope to hear your comments and idea. Thanks.

Kwikcad

CADmate

Designer

21 Jan, 2013
Hi PG,
I don&;t know how your Drafters experts check this mark ups and how rate the designer. As I can see there is no such things as a reducing tee the branch is bigger than the main header. as you can see that the line going out to T808A (4" Size) going to the Suction of the Pump which is 3" line. It should be connected to the 4" line also so that the you need to use a straight Tee. See your drawing.

Kwikcad

Designer

17 Jan, 2013
Can we have the list of the top designer?

pg

Buyer

17 Jan, 2013
We&;re still working on it. Our drafter expects to have revision requests (for top designs) out by Sunday.

GURU

Designer

17 Jan, 2013
@Pg any update on your winner selection list?

pschonfeldt

Designer

15 Jan, 2013
@pg We&;re almost at the end of the 7th business day.... Any winners yet?

pg

Buyer

8 Jan, 2013
@Merlin11 We&;re aiming to award the top 5 within 7-business days of contest close (closed January 7th). Thanks!

Merlin11

Designer

8 Jan, 2013
does someone win ?where is the list of winners?

CJEJVR

7 Jan, 2013
I guess I checked my email too late. I really wanted to submit on this but it was shorten by 10 days. I hope down the line they are still wanting to hire more freelancers.

Daniel

28 Dec, 2012
Mr MacKenzie Brown-

I really appreciated this ..hope now other do understand value of platform.

Daniel

yantsenme

Designer

27 Dec, 2012
Hi hiren patel
I&;m sorry if you did not have a family relationship, I assume you have a relationship because you have the same family name (surname). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patel. Please be advised ^_^. Thanks for correct me

Mac

Administrator

27 Dec, 2012
Hi Daniel,
Thanks for the info, I&;ll make sure to remove the entry & comment.
Thanks,
MacKenzie

Hiren Patel

Designer

27 Dec, 2012
Hi yantsenme,
I don&;t have any idea about pritesh patel I am only interested to do quality work for buyer so kindly don&;t connect me with any one please.

Daniel

27 Dec, 2012
@Yants..thanks for your comment hope mr. brown or his team have look on this sooon .. who is hiren patel ?

yantsenme

Designer

27 Dec, 2012
I agree with daniel, and what is you relationship with Hiren Patel ?

Daniel

27 Dec, 2012
Hi Mr Patel, Could please let me know what is relation between your sample work and client requirement as per my understanding u just post it to sell thing and u have written your name brand along with that so this kind of activity is strictly prohibited while working with crowd sourcing platform so don&;t u know this ?

I would like to draw attention of Mr. Brown and his team on this because if this is not going to be stop then platform will be not useful for good buyers or designer.

Sorry but I would love to have spammer free world sorry 

Daniel - Cad Artist

pg

Buyer

21 Dec, 2012
Hi guys, please note that we&;ve shortened the contest by 10 days because we&;ve had a fair amount of interest for this project. We&;ll provide our feedback to freelancers just before the project gets closed out.
Thanks

NehaParikh

Designer

19 Dec, 2012
I am not able to load the screenshot for the work that I have done

Similar Contests on Cad Crowd

Filter Skid
Simple gas filter skid, 2 filters in parallel with globe valves in the inlet and outlet
hedi taalouch
piping and support
AutoCAD Formatting Work - Freelance CAD Project
Formatting work for the attached 7 files with AutoCAD. Include both of the CSA logos on the drawings. We also want it noted that the valves are rated to -60C.
3D Design for Pump
This design contest is for an EPC (engineering procurement & construction) company that needs a pump designed with AutoCAD.
3d modelling
need help for modelling my pipeline autocad drawing into 3d model.